Sarfaraz Shah, a youth died in hope for mercy.
by Sonia Wahab
These are the last words of Sarfaraz Shah, murdered in cold blood by six paramilitary
rangers in Karachi. There is very little known to us that how this video was shot so closely and how it got a chance to spread so quickly through electronic media. Usually, the military incidents are kept highly confidential from public viewing and most of the time any activity of military rangers is never made available to the public media. It is becoming harder with the emerging advanced technology to control the information recording tools. The recording of Sarfarz Shah’s daylight murder is an alarming point for our institutions to consider their actions as the evidence can be made available. Now the technology has empowered people to share their views and bring their realities forefront.
The incident recorded clearly shows that six people from Pakistan paramilitary rangers who were fully armed, captured a young boy and on gun point they forced him to get in to an open space of the park. In this complete footage of 1 minute and 20 seconds Sarfarz Shah seemed begging for his life and fluttering like a Qurbani ka Bakra. The killers had no emotions on their faces and it seemed as if they all knew what they had to do. I don’t know the reason why this video clip reminded me exactly the time when every year we sacrifice animals on Eid day. I could feel a similar sense of determination and power in those eyes of butcher and those who force the animal lie down and then say ‘takbeer’. The nervousness and screams of Sarfarz were exactly like an animal who knows that there is no escape but one could at least beg for mercy. The scene of blood showering on the floor and a living body writhing in pain is not very unfamiliar to us. We see once every year how the animal bleed to death and in the mean while the butchers just stand there and wait when the animal shudder its body as a last sign of life. The surrounding is just filled with painful scream and nobody steps forward for help…
The last words of Sarfaraz Shah uttered in pain get recorded in the camera and we could hear and see that the young boy struggled for life until last few moments of his life. He still had hope that the killers had shot not to kill him and he could be saved with some quick medical aid. The last few seconds of the video ends with his cries for mercy to take him at least to the hospital and then he collapses on the ground all filled with his blood… again it resembles a site of animal sacrificed who could still smell the stench of its own fresh blood and perhaps expects mercy from those who stands there and watch the show.
According to the reports, Sarfaraz Shah was escaping from the rangers after committing some robbery. The military rangers caught him and the directives given were to shoot the criminals on the spot. In a media report it has been clarified by a military official that no man of rangers could shoot an unarmed man and the only fatal shot would be in their self-defense. In this clip Sarfaraz Shah is unarmed and visibly asking for mercy for life before bullet shots and then for medical aid before dying. The animals of sacrifice have no rights to life and medical aid when they are on alter, but at least human beings should be given this last chance. There are just little differences that separate crime and criminals from law and justice. We quite often forget to abhor crime not the criminal knowing the fact that capital punishments are still practiced in our system of law and justice. As I have learned from the lessons of civilization, the value of life and human blood is never so cheap. Although I know that we honor death in certain circumstances but life in itself is a biggest honor bestowed upon every living being with complete rights on it. I agree that sometimes human beings are vicious in taking this chance from others, but what difference lies if we still practice a decadent principle of a life for a life. As a nation we have seen a lot of bloodshed and have wasted many lives in just honoring death. I think that we should learn now that there is nothing valuable than a human being’s life and we should stop valorizing death in any form.
comrade haris
June 12, 2011
great..
Leo Safavid
June 12, 2011
Sonia has done what every literate Pakistani must do, repeat the episode, with all its gory details, again & again, and again, till the perpetrators are brought to justice. Not only that, but till the message from citizens rings loud and clear that ‘NEVER AGAIN! NEVER AGAIN!’. And, I think Sonia did it quite well.
BTW, does that picture not remind you of a famous photo of a South Vietnamese Officer killing a Vietnamese civilian point blank from his pistol? The expressions on the faces of both the victims are almost identical. If I remember correctly, that photo from Vietnam changed the whole course of Vietnam War and its approval by not only the American people but by the people of the whole world.. I hope this Pakistani video will do the same.
Imran Kamyana
June 12, 2011
Article is beautifully written. But the objective character of State (and things get worst in case of theocratic state as in the case of Pakistan) must be also be kept in mind. State itself is an institution of oppression. Its a tool in the hands of ruling class to oppress and exploit the toiling masses. As Engels explained beautifully what ‘state’ is: “Groups of armed people”
Secondly I don’t agree with your words “As a nation we have seen a lot of bloodshed . . . . ”
By saying so it seems like you agree that ‘nations’ can be formed (or in fact forged) on the basis of religion. “We” are not a nation. This is an artificial and historically bankrupt nation state. Problems faced by the masses in this part of the world can’t be solved withing post 1947 boundaries.
Emma Lewis
June 12, 2011
Neville Lewis, kingston Jamaica
what bothers me most is the fact that no one came to this young mans aid,surely
there would have been onlookers. it appears that he was shot in his lower body,
could someone not step forward and tied his would, instead they all watched a
human being lie there and bleed to death.It seems that life has become so cheap
and have no real value in pakistan like it is in my country. That footage was very disturbing.
The Mindset
June 13, 2011
The Religion of Peace ;D
PersonallyReligousPubliclySecular
June 14, 2011
I am resting my last hopes re our Pakistani society…. if we can call it one, in a quote from an Ancient Greek Playwright Aeschylus who said “Even in our sleep, pain which cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart until, in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom through the awful grace of God.”
Fob Squad
July 12, 2011
What up Everybody…
Article is well written. Props to the author.
I did want to add the fact that this murder had nothing to do with Islam and all to do with unchecked power and authority.
The Rangers and the Corrupt Government claims that Sarfaraz Shah was a thief. If this allegation is true, under Islamic law the worst punishment for a thief is getting their hand/arm chopped off…. they didn’t cut his arm or give him any sort of warning…let alone even bring the kid to trial… instead they shot him in cold blood.
There is no Shariah law for Muslims in Pakistan…. this is a well known fact. I know you guys are all for Secular Pakistan and I respect your opinions, however there is no Shariah law for Muslims in Pakistan.
Professor Ali
July 13, 2011
Hey guys, check out this recent piece that I wrote. I hope you guys find it interesting and entertaining. Please feel free to comment or re-post.
http://www.therealfobsquad.com/the-revolution-will-not-be-televised-pakistani-edition/
M Usman Malik
September 3, 2011
Can you quote a single reference where Quad e Azam has used the word “Secularism”, during his 40 years long struggle for independence?
Yasir Hameed
February 10, 2012
The issues pertaining to Pakistan are very well projected on Think Twice Pakistan.